Milwaukee man faces foreclosure because he didn’t pay parking fine

Submitted by:
Badger
Badger



Subscribe to this Author

Paste this code into your site to promote this story!


http://www.jsonline.com/story/index.aspx?id=779234
Type of Content: 
Article

The ticket went unpaid for four years, eventually amounting to $2,600 in fines
By RAQUEL RUTLEDGE
rrutledge@journalsentinel.com
Posted: Aug. 2, 2008
Peter Tubic ignored a $50 parking fine in 2004, and on Monday, it cost him his $245,000 house.

Foreclosure

Photo/Jeffrey Phelps

Among other health issues he's dealing with, Peter Tubic has had headaches dealing with his van, which is parked in his driveway without a license plates. He faces foreclosure on his home and is in a dispute with the city over citations he received for the van's lack of plates.

Nitty Gritty
A Milwaukee man received a $50 fine for parking a van with no license plates in his driveway. He ignored the ticket for more than four years, and last week the city foreclosed on his house.
Journal Sentinel Investigations

Main Page
Watchdog Reports
Public Investigator
Citizen Watchdog
Daniel Bice:
No Quarter
Data on Demand
Blow the Whistle
Advertisement

In what city officials believe is the first case of its kind, the city foreclosed on Tubic's house on W. Verona Court after repeated attempts to collect the fine - which over the years had escalated to $2,600 - had failed.

"Our goal isn't to acquire parcels," said Jim Klajbor, special deputy city treasurer. "Our goal is to just collect taxes. . . . It is only as a last resort that we would pursue . . . foreclosure."

Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Richard Sankovitz technically stayed the judgment to give Tubic one last chance to explain why he hasn't paid or even responded, but Sankovitz ruled in favor of the city's foreclosure.

"The city was entitled to a judgment," Sankovitz told Public Investigator on Thursday. "There hadn't been an answer to the complaint."

Tubic takes the blame for disregarding the 15 or more notices he received seeking payment and warning of the pending foreclosure on the house, which was fully paid off, but says he had good reason.

He was physically and psychologically unable to handle the situation, he says.

According to the Social Security Administration, Tubic, 62, has been disabled since 2001. He has been diagnosed with psychological disorders that limit his "ability to understand, remember and carry out detailed instructions," according to documents from the administration.

In addition he suffers from chronic pain caused by degenerative diseases of the knees and spine, as well as chronic respiratory disease, diabetes and obesity, among other ailments.

In several lengthy conversations with the P.I. Team spanning two weeks, Tubic frequently grunted in pain and broke down in tears.

"They're trying to take my house away for a parking violation," Tubic said. "I know it was my own fault for letting it drag on, I've been under mental duress. I haven't been able to handle this."

Janine Geske, a former Wisconsin Supreme Court justice and law professor at Marquette University, called the case a human tragedy and an example of how people can fall through the cracks in the system.

"It seems like a drastic remedy," Geske said of the city's foreclosure. "But on the other hand the city has to enforce its zoning laws. I don't fault the city for that.

"It's a shame someone didn't intervene to help him. . . . It would be nice if someone who worked for government would take the time and say 'let's look at this and see if we're doing the right thing.' . . . It would be nice if they would remember the human factor here."

Tubic first got the fine for parking his Ford E150 with no license plates in the driveway of the home, which belonged to his parents at the time . The radiator had broken and Tubic couldn't get his plates renewed unless the van passed an emissions test. He didn't have the money to make the repair and had more pressing worries, he said.

His father was suffering from dementia. His mother was battling cancer, and he was their live-in caretaker. He needed to shop, cook, clean, maintain the house and tend to his parents' needs.

The van repair could wait, he thought.

Then a man from the city showed up and told him otherwise. It was February 2004. Tubic would have to move the van or get license plates for it within 30 days, per city zoning codes, the man said. Somebody had complained.

Several days later Tubic's dad died. Tubic was overwhelmed, he said.

"It was a combination of things financial and emotional, my caregiving role, all heaped themselves on me at the wrong time," he said. "I still don't function well."

Month after month the city Department of Neighborhood Services sent an inspector

Read »

Created 22 weeks 4 days ago

Comments

Comment viewing options
Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
FASCISM at work

This is extremely outrageous. What has happened to Mr. Tubic's constitutional rights? The entire city should be screaming with outrage. This is evidence of a dictatorial government controlled business, which is the definition of FASCISM! The judge should be disrobed and disbarred. The press should be screaming for the personal liberty of this unfortunate man. In my opinion this man has been taken advantage of by a money hungry government that is too big for their britches. Shame on big government. It seems TYRANNY is being welcomed in Wisconsin with open arms. WAKE UP WISCONSIN, IS YOUR HOME NEXT, stealing of property by the government must not be a violation of any codes or law. The United States of America was formed “of the people, by the people and for the people”, this is no longer the government that our founding fathers had envisioned.

"That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government…”

RESTORE THE REPUBLIC

Badger Posted by Badger on Sun, 08/03/2008 - 8:28am
Comment viewing options
Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.